Skip to main content

NYC-Style Pizza and Sauce

The old way we made pizza was fine. Fantastic, even, compared to the thick slabs of greasy dough that pass for pizza at local chain restaurants. But after many years of enjoying our homemade pizzas, a seed of discontent was sown when my husband went on a business trip to New York City and sent me pictures of the delicious slices he enjoyed for dinner the night he arrived. The discontent grew when we vacationed at the NJ shore over the summer and devoured a plain pie with perfect crust, the whole family vying for the last piece. Maybe the salt air made everything taste better, but I left determined--we had to up our pizza game.

Combine that determination with a happy abundance of frozen tomato puree from our garden, and the stage is set for me to share our new favorite way to make pizza at home. We enjoy letting the slow simmered sauce, fresh cheese, and exquisite crust take center stage here, and usually serve it with a big tossed salad and sauteed zucchini and onions, but you can certainly load your pies up with whatever toppings you like.

I have been much helped in this venture by several articles from Serious Eats, and The Windowpane Test.  I used to have trouble with our dough sometimes, but since learning of this simple test it's turned out right every time. You should really read the whole article because the pictures are so informative, but to summarize, you know you're done kneading your dough when you can take a small ball of it (a "pizza for Barbie" amount) and stretch and pull it until it's a thin, translucent membrane with a visible gluten network and does not tear easily.

Our food processor unfortunately went kaput around the same time I began looking for new pizza recipes, so though the Serious Eats recipe actually recommends a food processor for fast kneading, I use my KitchenAid stand mixer, which is slower and allows more oxidation. Again, I recommend reading through the whole article for a discussion of kneading techniques, dough thickness, and ingredients, which are all important factors in making a true NYC-style crust. A period of refrigeration (up to 5 days before baking) encourages the flavor of the dough to develop, but I'll be honest--pizza is usually a thing we decide we want that night and not something I am fastidious about planning for, so sometimes we skip that step. Observant readers will note that already you find me deviating from SE's outstanding advice in two areas, but that's the rebellious life of a homemaker for you. The third is that I sometimes sub in up to a half cup of whole wheat flour for some of bread flour. Proceed at your own risk.

I follow the sauce recipe pretty much to the letter, except that I use puree made from our own garden tomatoes rather than store bought, and our own dried basil when fresh isn't available. This sauce is well balanced with wonderful flavor and smooth texture, neither too sweet nor too zesty. It needs to simmer at least an hour, so if I'm making the pizza dough the same night we intend to eat it (reiterating here that this is a rebel move), I get the sauce going first.

Though Serious Eats calls their recipes New York-style, I have added the C for City and for clarity, because these thin crust pizzas are definitely not the norm for upstate NY.

NYC-Style Pizza Sauce
1 28 oz. can whole peeled tomatoes, pureed with their juice
1 T. evoo
1 T. unsalted butter
2 medium cloves of garlic, minced
1 tsp. dried oregano
dash red pepper flakes
kosher salt
2 6" sprigs fresh basil with leaves attached, or 2 tsp. dried basil
1 medium yellow onion, peeled and split in half
1 tsp. sugar

In a saucepan over medium-low heat, combine the butter and olive oil. When the butter is melted, saute the garlic, oregano, pepper flakes, and a large pinch of salt until fragrant but not browned. Add the tomatoes, basil, onion, and sugar. Bring to a simmer, and cook over low heat, stirring occasionally, until reduced by half, at least 1 hour. Discard onions (and basil, if you've used whole stems). Season to taste with salt. Allow to cool and use immediately or refrigerate in a covered container for up to 2 weeks.

NYC-Style Pizza Dough
22 1/2 oz. (about 4 1/2 c.) bread flour, plus more for dusting
1 1/2 T. sugar
.35 oz. kosher salt (about 3 tsp.)
2 tsp. instant yeast
3 T. evoo
15 oz. lukewarm water
1 batch NYC Style Pizza Sauce
cheese and other toppings, as desired

Combine dry ingredients in the bowl of an electric food processor fitted with the dough blade, or a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment. Mix dry ingredients well. If using a stand mixer, switch to the dough hook. With your machine running on low speed, add the oil and water. Process until the dough is smooth and elastic and passes the windowpane test. This will probably take less than a minute with a food processor and around 7 minutes with a stand mixer. Transfer the dough ball to a lightly floured surface. Knead a few times by hand until a smooth ball is formed, then divide the dough into 3 even parts. Place each in a covered quart-size deli container or a zip top freezer bag, and allow to rise for 1-5 days in the refrigerator.

When you're ready to make your pizzas, shape the dough into 3 balls, coat in flour, and place each one in a separate bowl. Cover tightly with plastic wrap and allow to rise at warm room temperature until approximately doubled in volume. (1-2 hours, depending on the temperature of the dough.) An hour before baking, preheat your oven and pizza stone* to 500 degrees F. Working with a single dough ball at a time, press out into a rough 8" circle on a floured surface. Leave the outer edge 1" higher than the rest. Gently stretch the dough by draping over your knuckles into a 12-14" circle, and transfer to a pizza peel dusted with cornmeal. (This is the method outlined by the Serious Eats recipe. If you know how to spin pizzas like my husband does, obviously do that instead.)

Spread 1/3 of the sauce over the surface of the crust, leaving a 1/2-1" edge. Top with mozzarella (the recipe recommends full-fat dry mozzarella, freshly grated and placed in the freezer for 15 minutes before use; but fresh mozzarella is a treat) and other toppings as desired. Slide pizza onto baking stone and bake until cheese is melted with some browned spots and crust is golden brown and puffed. Our pizzas are usually done in about 8 minutes, some ovens may take longer.

*We have a FibraMent baking stone and wooden peel.

Note of business: Though I proofread multiple times, I sometimes notice mistakes in my writing after publishing and fix them, but these changes are usually not reflected by feed readers such as Feedly. Please visit for the most current version of a post.


Popular posts from this blog

Clay Cookie Craft

Though school is out for the summer there are a few things my little lass and I are still trying to work on consistently--reading, piano, and art.  Now, I have some fine art background but I don't consider myself very crafty, at least when in comes to coming up with fun projects for kids.  I loved this project from The Little Hands Art Book because it combined some great elements of cooking, sculpture, and painting.  I like crafts that actually teach something.  The bonus here is that we ended up with some great looking little cookies for my daughter's play kitchen.  Here's the salt dough recipe you need to get started (click on the photo to see it full size):

We left out the alum and baked the cookies.  We also halved the recipe.  I had my daughter (who is 4) pour the ingredients into a bowl and after I got the mixing started, I taught her how to knead the dough like bread.

The dough becomes smooth and pliable.

I split it into two sections to make it more manageable and l…

Quadro: The Coolest Toy You've Never Heard Of

Usually the content of my blog falls under either parenting, homemaking, or food.  Sometimes you get a poem or some thoughts as I meditate on what God is teaching me through his Word.  Usually my goal is to encourage, inspire, and perhaps amuse.  Today, my aim is not so noble--I just want to share a unique thing my family has been enjoying. 

This is Quadro--modular building toy, a prop for imaginative play, and active play equipment. 

Winters are always rather intense in our neck of the woods, but this one has been particularly frigid.  Nevertheless, my son asks to go outside to play pretty much every day.  I've had to say no a lot, or risk little frostbitten fingers or losing short stuff in a snow bank.  How's a little guy to burn off energy when running circles through the living and dining rooms gets old and his best playmate (his older sister) is busy with school?  This was one of our considerations as my husband and I discussed Christmas gifts for the kids this past yea…

Post-Christmas Reveal: Handmade Gifts for Kids

Quite a few secret projects have been underway here recently, and I'm thankful that there was time to finish them all before Christmas. My sewing machine has been a near constant fixture on the dining room table since Thanksgiving, and now that they've all been unwrapped by their intended recipients, I'm excited to share the fruits of my labors. :)

It's hard to come up with gift ideas for the youngest of 4, but my baby is outgrowing babydom and his hooded infant towels as well. I love the convenience of hooded towels, which make it so easy to scoop a little one out of a bath and quickly envelope them head to toe in warm coziness, and so I decided to make him some larger towels. This project used two full size bath towels and one matching hand towel, split in half and rounded off, to form the hoods. The center point of the hood was then matched to the center point of the bath towel, and attached, hems enclosed in bias tape, with a few rows of stitching. If you don'…